Beyond SEO vs GEO: How Nashville Businesses Should Actually Measure AI Traffic Impact

Google’s John Mueller made a point worth noting on Reddit recently. Someone asked the question every Nashville marketing director is secretly wondering: “Is SEO still enough, or do we need to start thinking about GEO too?”

His answer cut through the noise: “What you call it doesn’t matter, but ‘AI’ is not going away.”

GEO, short for Generative Engine Optimization, refers to optimizing content for AI-powered search tools like ChatGPT and Perplexity. The term has gained traction as marketers wonder whether traditional SEO still applies.

At Rank Nashville, we configure this tracking for clients regularly. The pattern is clear: stop arguing about labels, start measuring what actually matters.

The Real Question Mueller Wants You to Ask

Mueller didn’t validate GEO as a separate discipline. He didn’t dismiss it either. Instead, he reframed the entire debate with three questions:

• What percentage of your audience actually uses AI tools?
• How does that compare with search, social, or other channels?
• What does that mean for where you invest time and resources?

This is not philosophical. This is operational. And most Nashville businesses have no idea how to answer these questions because they’re not tracking AI-driven traffic in the first place.

The Measurement Gap Nobody Talks About

Here’s the uncomfortable reality: Google Analytics doesn’t break out “traffic from ChatGPT” as a default channel.

When someone in Green Hills asks ChatGPT “best Italian restaurant near me,” gets a recommendation with your URL, and clicks through—that visit can show up as direct traffic or get lumped into “unassigned” depending on how the click is passed. You’re flying blind.

Meanwhile, the SEO vs GEO debate continues on social media. Consultants coin new acronyms. Conference speakers build entire presentations around the terminology war. And actual Nashville business owners still can’t answer a basic question: “How much of my traffic comes from AI?”

How to Actually Track AI Referral Traffic in GA4

Good news: You can fix this today. Here’s how.

Step 1: Identify AI Referrer Domains

AI tools that send clickable traffic use specific domains:

• chatgpt.com — ChatGPT web interface
• chat.openai.com — Older ChatGPT domain
• gemini.google.com — Google’s Gemini
• claude.ai — Anthropic’s Claude
• perplexity.ai — Perplexity search
• copilot.microsoft.com — Microsoft Copilot

Step 2: Create a Custom Channel Group in GA4

Go to Admin → Data Display → Channel Groups → Create New.

Add a new channel called “AI Assistants” with this condition:

Set “Session source” (not page path or referrer) to “matches regex” and use:

chatgpt\.com|chat\.openai\.com|claude\.ai|perplexity\.ai|gemini\.google\.com|copilot\.microsoft\.com

Critical: Drag this new channel above “Referral” in the list. GA4 evaluates rules top to bottom—if Referral comes first, your AI traffic gets absorbed there.

Step 3: Build a Dedicated Report

Create an Exploration report filtering by AI source domains. Track sessions, engagement rate, and conversions. Run this weekly. Watch the trend.

One caveat: Not all AI traffic shows up cleanly. Some AI-driven visits don’t pass referrer data (copy/paste behavior, app browsers, certain configurations), so a portion lands in “Direct.” Your AI channel will capture what is trackable, but actual AI-driven traffic is likely higher than what GA4 reports.

Don’t Want to Configure This Yourself?

We set up AI traffic tracking for Nashville businesses as part of our analytics work. If you’d rather have this done right the first time, reach out for a free consultation and we’ll handle the setup.

What Nashville Industries Should Expect

When we audit Nashville businesses and set up AI tracking, clear patterns emerge by industry. These observations come from our client accounts and may vary based on audience, content type, and measurement setup.

Higher AI traffic potential:

Nashville’s growing tech sector tends to see meaningful AI referral traffic. The city’s SaaS startups, health tech companies, and software consultancies serve audiences that skew technical. These users adopted ChatGPT early and use it daily for research.

Healthcare information sites also fall here. Nashville’s health tech companies, wellness brands, and anyone publishing medical content often see AI referrals. People frequently ask AI for health information before (or instead of) calling a doctor.

Moderate AI traffic:

Professional services sit in this middle zone. Nashville’s law firms, accounting practices, and consulting shops tend to see some AI traffic—especially for research-phase queries. Someone asking “what questions should I ask a divorce attorney” might start with ChatGPT. But when they’re ready to hire, they’ll Google “divorce attorney Nashville” and click the Local Pack.

Lower AI traffic:

Here’s where it gets interesting for Nashville’s core economy. Local service businesses—your plumbers, HVAC techs, roofers, electricians—typically see minimal AI referral traffic.

Why? Intent and urgency. When your AC dies on an August afternoon in Brentwood, you’re not having a conversation with Claude about HVAC repair options. You’re Googling “emergency AC repair near me” and calling the first number you see.

Same logic applies to Nashville’s restaurant and hospitality sector. Tourists walking down Broadway are less likely to ask Perplexity where to get hot chicken—they’re searching Google Maps or asking the hotel concierge. You’ll see this pattern in your own channel mix once you start tracking.

The Strategic Implication for Nashville Businesses

Mueller’s point becomes actionable once you have actual data. This is exactly what we help clients figure out.

If you’re a Nashville SaaS company and AI drives 12% of your qualified traffic—growing 40% quarter over quarter—yes, you need an AI visibility strategy. Call it GEO, call it AI optimization, call it whatever. The label doesn’t matter. The investment does.

If you’re a Nashville roofing company and AI drives 0.3% of your traffic, flat for six months—don’t abandon your local SEO strategy chasing a new acronym. Your customers aren’t using AI to find roofers. They’re using Google, and they’re clicking the Map Pack.

This is what Mueller meant by “be realistic and look at actual usage metrics.”

The Overlap Is Real (But Not Complete)

Google’s Search Liaison has emphasized: “Good SEO is good GEO.” Danny Sullivan has said it repeatedly. The fundamentals overlap—clear content, strong E-E-A-T signals, solid technical SEO.

But “mostly overlapping” isn’t “identical.”

AI models cite sources differently than Google ranks pages. Perplexity might surface a Reddit comment that would never crack Google’s top 100. ChatGPT might recommend a competitor that ranks nowhere for your target keywords.

A Nashville law firm dominating “personal injury attorney Nashville” in Google might be invisible when someone asks ChatGPT “who are the best injury lawyers in Nashville?” Different systems, different logic, different results.

Search visibility doesn’t automatically equal AI visibility. Mueller acknowledged this when he said to consider “the full picture.”

Your Action Plan

Stop treating this as binary. It’s not SEO versus GEO. It’s portfolio allocation based on evidence. Here’s the timeline we recommend to clients:

Week 1: Set up tracking. Implement the GA4 custom channel group. We can do this for you, or you can follow the steps above. Either way, you can’t make strategic decisions without data.

Week 2-4: Collect baseline. Let the data accumulate. Resist the urge to draw conclusions from three days of traffic.

Month 2: Analyze by page type. Your blog content might get heavy AI referrals while your service pages get almost none. That tells you something about where AI optimization matters.

Month 3: Follow the money. AI traffic means nothing if it doesn’t convert. Compare conversion rates: AI referrals versus organic search versus direct. This is where we help clients decide whether AI traffic is worth chasing or a distraction.

Quarterly: Reassess. AI adoption is shifting fast. What’s true in Q1 might flip by Q3. Build measurement into your regular reporting cadence.

The Bottom Line

John Mueller gave Nashville businesses permission to ignore the terminology war. SEO, GEO, AIO—the acronym doesn’t matter.

What matters: understanding how your specific audience finds you, measuring the channels that drive revenue, and allocating resources accordingly.

For most Nashville local businesses, that still means Google. For Nashville tech companies, the calculus is shifting.

The only way to know which camp you’re in? Measure it.

Stop debating. Start tracking.

Need Help Setting This Up?

If you want to track AI traffic but do not have time to configure GA4 yourself, we can help. As a Nashville SEO agency, our team sets up custom channel groups, builds reporting dashboards, and shows you clearly where your business stands in the AI-versus-traditional-search mix.

Request a Free SEO Audit and we’ll include an AI referral tracking review—channel group setup and report validation—as part of your analysis.

Fact-Check Table